JEDI Comport

I've noticed this...when you put your saber away to switch to melee, it just disappears...I wonder, if It's possible to take the holster option (from JA+) and add it so that the saber "clips" onto the belt. Just an idea.

It definatly would add to the realism. I know nothing about modding so I don't know if it would be hard or not. If it is easy to do, it would be a nice feature, but if it is hard to do, I don't know if it would be worth the trouble. I know the saberstaff goes on your back though.

yeah i really like that aspect of the JA+ mod.. i remember being a guest in the ::JEDI:: server long ago when JA+ was being used.. The belt clip feature was available as well as the hands to the side while in melee.

I do indeed miss this when you clip the lightsaber onto your belt, hope you bring it back in the future

I agree with this.

I'm curious as to what they are proposed to look like? A hunk of metal sticking out of one's hip?

I found the simple saber to belt to be dysfunctional for various models, the Luke/Jacen/Anakin Solo models to be exact. And various amounts of clipping on other models, my old Fisto model for one.

But I suppose if this were to come to reality, there would be a no holster or hidden option. But I find looking at someone's lightsaber attached to their thigh to be a bit... annoying.

Then you can reskin the model with a belt right there or something. I don't know if this is accurate or not, but in the movies the loops on lightsabers were on the bottom, so if you made the hilt clip upside down or something.

Tinthros Vos wrote:Then you can reskin the model with a belt right there or something.

Thats not the issue, the issue is of where the saber is programmed to be in fist mode. Take Gabe's model for example, it would look very odd if you were to lower the belt by several IC inches.

Wouldnt it be better if the saber was a few cm under the belt instead of disappearing completely ?

It was a nice effect on some models, but yeah, clipping issues are too common... I don't miss it so much that it pains me. Now, the wall hanging grab on the other hand I do miss... In my opinion the grab we have now looks like one is suspended from an invisible rope, and we're Jedi, not Fakir. Any chance we can use the old animation in the next release?

I quickly tried to implement it but there are several problems (other than clipping): the saber is too high on the belt/hip, and it appears even if you aren't supposed to have a saber (like guests/hopefuls). I didn't find any easy way to fix that. As this feature is not really a priority, I won't go further for the moment. Maybe in a future version, but not 0.3.0.

Jared: the Ledge Grab bug is not related to the animation itself, it's because of the model scale (an unscaled model would work fine). It's already fixed for version 0.3.0.

I personally wouldn't want the saber clipped to my side. I tend to wear skins that don't support this, and don't WANT to have to skin on a belt that would ruin my designs. If this gets implemented, I'd like a feature to turn it off if we choose.

After reading everyones posts i think it would be best not to have it unless it was bug free.. Still is a cool feature though

After reading further, I tend to agree, if it cannot be bug free, it is probably best not to try to implement it.