JEDI Comport

I don't know about you guys, but I often find it very strange as to why the absorb sound has to be so loud. It doesn't sound very realistic to RP in my opinion. So, here's my opinion; what if this sound were to be changed so that maybe:

1) Either the volume of the sound is lowered somehow.
2) A new sound replaces it.
3) Possibly an optional setting, to somehow deactivate Absorb sounds.
4) The volume is altered and the sound length is reduced. (because the length of the sound is quite long.)

What are your thoughts? I might sound completely stupid, but I think it's slightly disturbing as when you're in a middle of a duel (as I've watched) and you hear these big, crazy noises out of nowhere.

"Power" is often emphasized by sound.
It's like in some space movies with a ship explodes in the distance you hear an instant BANG!!!
In truth, sound would take time to travel to the camera's location so there would be no instant BANG when the ship explodes.
However, in cinema, if there is an explosion and no sound, people would feel less impacted by it and a bit let-down. I'm all for realism in most cases but pursuing Realism relentlessly without faltering can have negative impacts with something that is a Sci-Fi Fantasy.

I agree the noise shouldn't last so long but to mute it entirely for example, would make me feel a bit odd.

The main problem I have with force sound effects is it draws people's attention in RP when really it shouldn't.
Mind trick for example. When people hear that familiar Mind Trick noise, they instantly spin around trying to find the person.


Ahhhh this is a tough one.. I'm half yes, half no!
I think quietening it, as you said, might be a happy medium?
There is always the option of altering your own assets folder to replace the sound with something silent or a quietened version.

"I agree the noise shouldn't last so long but to mute it entirely for example, would make me feel a bit odd."

1) Either the volume of the sound is lowered somehow.
2) A new sound replaces it.
3) Possibly an optional setting, to somehow deactivate Absorb sounds.
4) The volume is altered and the sound length is reduced. (because the length of the sound is quite long.)

I don't want it to be muted entirely for the same reason. Meaning, that I wish for it to be altered.

It'd be easy to edit these sounds using a program like Audacity to reduce the volume of each file as a temporary fix. However, the force power itself has a looping sound effect.

The sounds are located in:

"assets0.pk3"
sound / weapons / force

The sounds are:

absorb.mp3
absorbhit.mp3
absorbloop.wav

I could personally create some sounds using a synthesiser myself and I could use FL Studio to reduce the volume of those sounds/master them slightly. It depends whether or not it's a good suggestion.

You could do it and offer an optional download. A better compromise for those who aren't bothered by the sounds.

Zeak Dystiny wrote:You could do it and offer an optional download. A better compromise for those who aren't bothered by the sounds.

I like the idea of that; because I'm sure a lot of people are comfortable with the sounds as they are. Hmm. Do you reckon I should make an optional sound? I'd be happy to start it right away.

The mind trick and sense are the most bothersome sounds in RP!

Liezl Myrin wrote:The mind trick and sense are the most bothersome sounds in RP!

All right... Hm... If we remove the mind trick sound, other people will not notice that they have been mind tricked. However, rply in the star wars universe, mind tricks are quite basic and cannot work on weak-minded individuals... I'm confusing myself, you may ignore that last sentence if you wish. I would mute the sense sound completely because it's just ridiculous for me as well, it might work better in RP. "I sense so and so." Instead of: "BIG FAT STUPID SOUND" "I sense so and so." (( People turn to the guy who used sense *before* he says it. ))

Think that sensing sound has been disabled. If it hasn't, I don't notice it :happy:

I think all sounds should be disabled. Except push and pull.

But I don't think that this idea is popular among the other members.

To me, less is more.

If you can edit a skin, you have the potential to edit sounds. Find the appropriate pk3 file, identify which sounds you are a wuss to, and create/find more suitable sounds (I'm partial to a .WAV file that has no sound for 2 seconds), and start a new pk3 with the same directory, and the new sounds named as the sounds you want to change, and save that pk3, naming it as something that will load AFTER the original sounds (e.g. something AFTER assets# or RPmodassets).

Badda-bing! Badda-boom!
Quit yer bitchin'.

Personally I think all the sounds for Force abilities should be removed, except maybe something like the Force Lightning sound. If you truly pay attention to the movies and such, there is no sound for when you use the Force to jump, to push objects, pull them.. all that stuff. The only sound you really get from a Force power is lightning.

So I personally think all but lightning should get there sounds removed.

*Ehm* Telekinesis does indeed produce a sound, it's a low-frequency effect imitating a heavy thud of sorts. This can, among other things, be seen in the duel of the fates when Darth Maul pushes down Anakin. And truth be told, protect may very well produce a sound as well, considering it's a barrier of energy that is suddenly generated.