JEDI Comport » ((JEDI RolePlay Mod/RPMod)) » Suggestions
-
Notifications ()
Notifications Settings
- You have no notifications
Three strike, temporary ban.
- Simus Cnydaria
- Lost One
- Posts: 2500
- Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 1:29 am
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Heh, well put Amone! Touche. And I like the idea of a 12 hour temp ban. I was thinking 24 but 12 sound more reasonable. And Kih I support your command ideas. I think that's a good way to make the admining efficient and not leaving room for any "oopses." The admining is very intentional for its purposes.
- Amoné Fayden
- Lost One
- Posts: 1159
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 1:55 am
- Location: Rori
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
That would work too!Kih Bu wrote:Just a thought, could we maybe have a /rppingkick or alternatively an /rptempkick? The temp kick being used 3 times consecutively resulting in the temporary ban, or implemting the temporary ban to the regular /rpkick and then creating /rppingkick to boot stuck players?
Agreed.
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Instead of multiplying commands for the single use case of players pinging out, kicks done while the player has a ping equal to 999 could simply not be counted as 'strikes'. The server does know the player's ping.Kih Bu wrote:Just a thought, could we maybe have a /rppingkick or alternatively an /rptempkick? The temp kick being used 3 times consecutively resulting in the temporary ban, or implemting the temporary ban to the regular /rpkick and then creating /rppingkick to boot stuck players?
- Simus Cnydaria
- Lost One
- Posts: 2500
- Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 1:29 am
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Now why didn't we think of that? Brilliant. LolSoh Raun wrote:Instead of multiplying commands for the single use case of players pinging out, kicks done while the player has a ping equal to 999 could simply not be counted as 'strikes'. The server does know the player's ping.Kih Bu wrote:Just a thought, could we maybe have a /rppingkick or alternatively an /rptempkick? The temp kick being used 3 times consecutively resulting in the temporary ban, or implemting the temporary ban to the regular /rpkick and then creating /rppingkick to boot stuck players?
The only problem I see is there have been a couple times where people were pinging out, and I kicked them accidentally just when they were stopping. So the intention was to ping kick them but I just had bad timing. But the odds that that would stack 3 times is a rare I think.
We should discuss when the stacks of kicks should reset.
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Well by design it looks like it'd be after the temporary ban expires.Simus Cnydaria wrote: We should discuss when the stacks of kicks should reset.
If it's three strikes a cool thing to do would be, if they rejoin after the second kick, to have Console whisper their player when they reach spectator something to the effect of a final warning telling them the next kick will result in a temporary ban with a suggestion to check out the rules on the site.
| Oberon Pentari |
- Amoné Fayden
- Lost One
- Posts: 1159
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 1:55 am
- Location: Rori
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Could do.Oberon wrote: If it's three strikes a cool thing to do would be, if they rejoin after the second kick, to have Console whisper their player when they reach spectator something to the effect of a final warning telling them the next kick will result in a temporary ban with a suggestion to check out the rules on the site.
Or have admins (namely the one that kicked him/her) PM them a warning upon return or before their next kick.
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Naaah, too much effort. If we wanted to do that just give em the ability to temp ban.Amoné Fayden wrote: Could do.
Or have admins (namely the one that kicked him/her) PM them a warning upon return or before their next kick.
| Oberon Pentari |
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
If no one minds me making this contribution, I do think that an easier solution to all of this would be to permit those with Watchman admin the use of the /rpban command. They would still be expected to adhere to the three strike rule, as well as be required to file one of the Temple Violation Logs stating precisely who, why and when the ban was initiated.
Saying that, if any of the above from the previous posts can be implemented, that would still serve as a convenience - particularly for keeping track of the number of kicks. Though, maybe there is a solution as well. Could we add a value for how many times a person has been kicked? /rpkick Oberon Because I felt like it perhaps reading:
Oberon was kicked (2). Reason: Because I felt like it.
(2) Indicating that he has been kicked twice today, a number produced automatically and reset everyday. Then, if anyone is banned unfairly (on their first or second strike), everyone present knows about it - as well as anyone checking the server logs against the reported Temple Violation Log post - which should be obligatory when initiating a ban against anyone.
Saying that, if any of the above from the previous posts can be implemented, that would still serve as a convenience - particularly for keeping track of the number of kicks. Though, maybe there is a solution as well. Could we add a value for how many times a person has been kicked? /rpkick Oberon Because I felt like it perhaps reading:
Oberon was kicked (2). Reason: Because I felt like it.
(2) Indicating that he has been kicked twice today, a number produced automatically and reset everyday. Then, if anyone is banned unfairly (on their first or second strike), everyone present knows about it - as well as anyone checking the server logs against the reported Temple Violation Log post - which should be obligatory when initiating a ban against anyone.
-
JKHub | JEDI Videos | Files
i¯i▀▀▀▀▀i¯i‾°δ‾‾Pך
- Amoné Fayden
- Lost One
- Posts: 1159
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 1:55 am
- Location: Rori
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Lol!
I already said that Kih!
I already said that Kih!
Amoné Fayden wrote: As an extra thought, could there be a line that it displayed automatically as part of the kick message which would say what "strike" the player is on?
For example:And so on...
- Delmi kicks player "idiot".
- Server says: "Idiot was kicked: <reason> (First Kick)"
- Azra'el connects (oblivious to the first kick)
- "Idiot" connects.
- Azra'el kicks "idiot"
- Server says: "Idiot was kicked: <reason> (Second Kick)"
Further to that! Perhaps a command could be implemented that would inform an admin on how many kicks have been logged against a player (perhaps using their IP in the algorithm) within that day?
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
So it does, I must've missed that. Ah well, at least it shows that I'm in agreement with you if nothing else!
-
JKHub | JEDI Videos | Files
i¯i▀▀▀▀▀i¯i‾°δ‾‾Pך
- Amoné Fayden
- Lost One
- Posts: 1159
- Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 1:55 am
- Location: Rori
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
High Five!
It does look like there are a few ways to approach this.
What are you thinking Soh?
It does look like there are a few ways to approach this.
What are you thinking Soh?
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
I think that the original idea of a temporary ban after a number of "strikes" is valid, and would prefer it over giving /rpban to Watchmen. A permanent IP ban isn't something done lightly, and it should only be done by the highest ranking administrators (i.e. the Council) to avoid potential disputes with the banned player and - if the ban was abusive - to avoid contradicting our own Knights (which can damage their authority). We have had our problems with such contradiction in the past with regards to forum moderation (Axem, if you hear us..)
This being said, in practice I think displaying the current number of strikes is a good idea. Although instead of applying a simple "reset" every day (at which time anyway?), I would rather be for decrementing the "strikes" counter after a few hours with no kick (e.g. 3 hours). For example:
What do you think?
This being said, in practice I think displaying the current number of strikes is a good idea. Although instead of applying a simple "reset" every day (at which time anyway?), I would rather be for decrementing the "strikes" counter after a few hours with no kick (e.g. 3 hours). For example:
- A player strongly misbehaves, is kicked twice in an hour, comes back less than 3 hours after his last kick and is again kicked by an admin => he would be temporarily banned (he's had enough chances that day).
- A player is kicked twice in an hour, then behaves better... 3 hours after his last kick, his "strikes counter" is back to "1", and if he continues to behave well for 3 more hours it goes back to "0" => no auto ban in his case, since he improved.
What do you think?
- Simus Cnydaria
- Lost One
- Posts: 2500
- Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2008 1:29 am
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
Sounds good. You are truly the rpmod guru, Soh
- Illrian Damaris
- Lost One
- Posts: 1425
- Joined: Thu Apr 15, 2010 3:15 pm
- Location: Enclave on Alzoc III
- Contact:
Re: Three strike, temporary ban.
I haven't posted here because I just didn't feel like it, I like the idea of this three strike system, and honestly I think what you posted Soh is the best idea for it. Because someone can get the hint after but a few hours and change...so why should that last kick be on him for the entire day..
I say, we if go with the three strike system we go with what you posted, Soh, as that would be wonderful.
I say, we if go with the three strike system we go with what you posted, Soh, as that would be wonderful.
| species_zabrak | age_55 | defender |
| initiated_280.17 | mentor_aayla vigil |
| knighted_298.25 | padawan_sawyer snow.rui vuusen |
| initiated_280.17 | mentor_aayla vigil |
| knighted_298.25 | padawan_sawyer snow.rui vuusen |